As more of our daily and professional lives move online, both personal and company security depends on all of us. Cyber attacks and data breaches unfortunately continue, with password management often cited as an easy step to mitigate risk.
But how can you trust a company to keep all of your secrets secret? The answer lies in end-to-end encryption, which lays the groundwork for applications with ‘zero knowledge’ architectures.
In a TechRadar piece, author Christian Rigg noted,
Zero knowledge refers to policies and architecture that eliminate the possibility for a password manager to access your password.
While this is a perfect explanation of zero knowledge for a broad audience, security experts will differ in the interpretation of zero knowledge. For example, some competing password managers will claim zero knowledge, when in reality they offer only partial zero knowledge, monitoring unencrypted URLs and websites within user Vaults.
We know we want zero knowledge in terms of safely handling encrypted passwords with password managers, but what exactly does that mean?
The foundation of a secure architecture starts with encryption, specifically end-to-end encryption. At Bitwarden we encrypt your sensitive data immediately as soon as you enter it in any Bitwarden client, providing an end-to-end encrypted password manager. Before storing the data on your device, it is encrypted. There is no such thing as unencrypted Vault data, except when you are in control, viewing the information in a Bitwarden client where you have entered your email address and Master Password.
From there, all Vault data remains encrypted when sent to the Bitwarden Cloud or a self-hosted Bitwarden server. Upon synchronizing the data to other clients, it remains encrypted until the unique email address and master password are re-entered.
Bitwarden is a zero-knowledge encryption password manager. This means that Bitwarden as a company cannot see your passwords. They remain encrypted end-to-end with your individual email and Master Password. Bitwarden never stores and cannot access your Master Password.
For Vault data, Bitwarden uses AES 256-bit encryption, an industry standard, which is considered unbreakable. For your Master Password, PBKDF2 SHA-256 is used to derive the key that encrypts your Vault data. To read more about Bitwarden end-to-end encryption and Bitwarden security, please visit our security FAQ.
Understandably, the important detail of end-to-end encryption is the key to decrypt. As long as this remains only with the end user, a solution can progress to a zero knowledge architecture.
There are cases where software and service providers promote encryption but retain the key. These cases do not qualify as zero knowledge from our perspective since the software and service providers technically have the ability to decrypt the data.
When users have control of the encryption key, they control access to the data, and can provide encrypted data to a password manager without the password management company having access to, or knowledge of, that data.
This is the fundamental premise on which well-designed password managers work. They facilitate strong and unique passwords that only you can access. Doing so requires zero knowledge of the secret data, and therefore users must control the encryption key. We refer to this as zero knowledge encryption.
But there is information beyond the secret Vault data that might be shared with a software or service provider. For example, an email address might serve as a unique customer identifier. One could claim that this isn’t zero knowledge, and that would be correct.
At a minimum, zero knowledge must pertain to secret data. In the case of a password manager, that means all information within the password Vault. At the same time, it is important to recognize the realities of software, services, and users, and that in order for a commercial relationship to exist, there needs to be some knowledge exchanged between parties.
In the world of password managers, that line can get blurry. As previously mentioned, there are some password managers (not Bitwarden) that retain unencrypted URLs and websites for which you store passwords. While they claim that this benefits users, ultimately it provides these companies with detailed information on which websites users visit, when they do so, and every log in.
Bitwarden takes a more conservative view of what constitutes sensitive data, and therefore encrypts all of the information in your Vault, including the websites you visit, even the names of your individual items and folders. We use the term zero knowledge encryption because only you retain the keys to your Vault, and the entirety of your vault is encrypted. Bitwarden cannot see your passwords, your websites, or anything else that you put in your Vault. Bitwarden also does not know your Master Password. So take good care of it, because if it gets lost, the Bitwarden team cannot recover it for you.
Update: In 2021, Bitwarden introduced account recovery (formerly Admin Password Reset), which enables users and organizations to implement a new policy that allows administrators and owners to reset passwords. The new feature remains consistent with the Bitwarden zero-knowledge encryption model. For more information, please read Admin Password Reset is Here - Top Things for Enterprises to Know.
The zero trust model initially emerged as a way for organizations to get beyond the traditional thinking of internal and external threats to their IT operations. Today, companies need to protect from threats coming from both inside and outside. Zero trust models often use technologies like identity and access management, encryption, multi-factor authentication, and permissions to operate.
Of course, between password managers and users adopting software or services, there is likely going to be at least some element of trust between the two parties. The password management provider trusts that the user will not violate the terms of service, and the user trusts that the password management provider will live up to their stated offering. However, everyone is better off if the boundaries of required trust are limited, so that even the possibility of sensitive data being compromised is eliminated altogether, hence the zero trust model.
While we support our customers with a trusted relationship, we can reduce the reliance on implied trust through the Bitwarden self-hosted offering. This deployment enables businesses with greater flexibility and control over their infrastructure. Running your own Bitwarden instance could be on an air gap network, further reducing risks by being disconnected from the internet.
At Bitwarden we take this trusted relationship with our users seriously. We also built our solution to be safe and secure with end-to-end encryption for all Vault data, including website URLs, so that your sensitive data is zero trust secure.
We want our users to be well-informed on security practices, and the benefits Bitwarden provides. With encryption, seek a complete end-to-end encryption architecture where only the end user retains the key, and make sure all sensitive data is encrypted using that architecture.
For many, it is easier to understand zero knowledge than end-to-end encryption. Bitwarden strives for ease of use, but we also understand the intricacies of these terms and aim to maintain clear definitions. We hope this article helps clarify the Bitwarden philosophy and approach.
You can get started with an individual plan for yourself, or create a Bitwarden Organization to securely share information among other users, teams, or enterprises. Explore which Bitwarden plan is right for you.
WEBCAST: Building a Zero Knowledge Architecture for Password Management with End-to-end Encryption. Watch the replay
Editor’s note: This blog was originally published on August 6, 2020 and updated on December 21, 2021.